BACKGROUND ON COVANTA TRASH INCINERATOR
Covanta operates the largest trash incinerator in the U.S. in Chester, PA and is located on the Delaware River and Highland Avenue. The incinerator burns municipal solid waste to generate electricity and handles 1.2 million tons of garbage per year. The trash is sourced from Delaware County, Philadelphia, New Jersey all the way up to New York City.
Often rebranded as ‘waste-to-energy’, ‘energy from waste”, or “resource recovery”, trash incineration is the most polluting way to manage waste or to make energy. It is a public relations spin to gussy up a very dirty and inefficient industry. The facility processes 2,400 tons of waste per day, and at maximum output, generates approximately 75 megawatts of electricity per day. The toxic ash that remains after the trash is burned is then hauled to Rolling Hills landfill in Bucks County.
History of Trash Incineration in Chester
Like many post-industrial cities in the United States, Chester’s decline post-war was a result of many major industries closing, as well as deep political corruption and systemic racism that encouraged separatism and “white-flight”.
After the civil rights protests in the 1960’s to end to de-facto segregation of Chester schools, housing and businesses, white population began to plummet, as black population increased. Demographics in the 70’s-80’s demonstrate the transition and stark color divide between black and white populations in Delaware County. By 1990, the census reported that about 60% of residents were Black, 25% living below the poverty line and 20% were unemployed.
In the 1980’s, investors began looking at Chester as the optimal location for toxic and hazardous waste treatment facilities as the state’s landfills neared capacity, and governments began looking for alternative solutions to deal with the mounting trash problem. A Pittsburgh investment company known as Russell, Rea & Zappala (now Gomulka) saw the opportunity of a vulnerable town and began to buy up abandoned lots in Chester and build waste treatment facilities throughout the 1980’s.
In 1988, the PA Department of Environmental Protection granted a permit for a waste incineration facility. The facility Westinghouse promised 110 jobs and $2.7 million in revenue to the Chester City Council through taxes and fees. In 1991, Westinghouse opened a trash to steam plant in Chester that brought in trucks from Delaware, New Jersey, New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania. The energy produced from the "trash to steam" facility was sold to the city of Atlantic City, NJ.
In order to deliver garbage to the incinerator, over 350 18-wheel trucks drove down the residential Thurlow Street every day starting at 4 am. Chester residents complained about the noise and dust associated with the constant stream of trucks. The traffic made it dangerous for children to play in front of their homes and the garbage from the trucks brought rats, strange powder residues and awful smells.In 1992, Chester Mayor Barbara-Bohannan Shepherd called a town meeting of Chester residents, government officials, industry representatives, DEP and EPA to host a meeting associated with complaints regarding Westinghouse.
Residents feeling that their voices were falling on deaf ears started a formal citizen advocacy group: Chester Residents Concerned for Quality Living. CRCQL led a series of protests and blockades at the incinerator and at the county seat in Media from 1962-'63. Westinghouse responded to the actions by building a new access road for trucks as well as paying a $356,000 penalty for pollution violations during that period.
In 1995 a new medical waste treatment facility Thermal Pure opened followed by the plans to operate a contaminated soil processing facility near the active trash incinerator. The PA Dept. of Environmental Protection continued to grant permits for waste treatment and other toxic industries to operate within a cluster of 4 miles next to a densely populated low-income neighborhood. In response, CRCQL filed a complaint in Federal Court in Pennsylvania accusing the state's Department of Environmental Protection of racial discrimination. The legal action gained national attention as it was the first environmental racism lawsuit filed in the U.S. Over the next two years, the case wound its way through the appeals process until the Supreme Court declared that the case against the state's DEP to be moot, as the specific reason for the suit, Soil Reclamation Services, which was granted permission from the state to operate, was denied their operation permit while the case was in appeals.
In June 2005, Covanta acquired the facility which is now referred to as Covanta Delaware Valley Resource Recovery Facility.
HEALTH PROBLEMS FROM POLLUTION
Covanta’s Chester incinerator uses less pollution controls than any other incinerator in the state and the fewest of any of their fleet of 39 incinerators nation-wide. It currently lacks controls to reduce nitrogen oxides (NOx) that cause asthma and carbon injection to remove additional toxic metals and dioxins. Despite being the largest trash incinerator in the county, Covanta in Chester operates with less emission control standards than most other incinerators in operation.
In 2017, according to data reported to the state DEP on industrial sources of air pollution,
Covanta Plymouth released:
1,043,624 TONS of greenhouse gases (CO2 equivalents)
2,473,256 pounds of Nitrogen Oxides (NOx)
772,147 pounds of Carbon Monoxide (CO)
177,200 pounds of Sulfur Oxides (SOx)
120,940 pounds of Particulate Matter (PM10)85,980 pounds of Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.5)
16,685 pounds of Hydrochloric Acid
13,080 pounds of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
43 pounds of Mercury (19,504 grams)
38 pounds of Lead
24 pounds of Nickel
9 pounds of Chromium
8 pounds of Cadmium
6 pounds of Arsenic
A study in 2005 found that children in Chester have asthma rates FIVE TIMES (5x) the national average, and rate of childhood asthma hospitalization in Chester is 3x the rate for Pennsylvania, and double the rate for the rest of Delaware County. (2010 census data from The Asthma Program, PA Dept. of Health- Data provided by Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council).
As for its neighbor, Philly is ranked the 4th worst place in the nation for asthma suffers, according to Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America. The report singles out the city of brother love as an example where poverty, poor air quality, and lack of access to healthcare specialists combine to harm asthma sufferers, especially children. It states that “low-income minority children have some of the highest asthma rates of any group in the U.S.” The report also defines asthma as one of the most costly diseases- with an estimated annual cost to society of $82 billion nationally, which breaks down to $349 million per year for Philly. (see EJN- Phila testimony document for sources).
The Chester Risk Assessment Project, part of an initiative by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region III and agencies of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania conducted a study of the environmental risks, health and regulatory issues in Chester in 1994, a few years after the first waste treatment facilities were opened.
- Blood lead levels in the children of Chester unacceptable high with over 60% of the samples above the CDC’s recommended maximum level.
- Both cancer and non-cancer risks, e.g. kidney and liver disease and respiratory problems, from the pollution sources at locations in the city of Chester exceed levels which EPA believes are acceptable
- Air emissions from facilities in and around Chester provide a large component of the cancer and non-cancer risk to the citizens of Chester
- The health risks from eating contaminated fish from streams in Chester and the Delaware River is unacceptably high